Should a Company Issue Debt or Equity? (2024)

Businesses often need external moneyto maintain their operationsand invest in future growth. There are two types of capital that can be raised:debt and equity.

Debt Capital

Debt financing is capital acquired through the borrowing of funds to be repaid at a later date. Common types of debt are loans and credit. The benefit of debt financing is that it allows a business to leverage a small amount of money into a much larger sum, enabling more rapid growth than might otherwise be possible.

In addition, payments on debt are generally tax-deductible. The downside of debt financing is that lenders require the payment of interest, meaning the total amount repaid exceeds the initial sum. Also, payments on debt must be made regardless of business revenue. For smaller or newer businesses, this can be especially dangerous.

Equity Capital

Equity financing refers to funds generated by the sale of stock. The main benefit of equity financing is that funds need not be repaid. However, equity financing is not the "no-strings-attached" solution it may seem.

Shareholders purchase stock with the understanding that they then own a small stake in the business. The business is then beholden to shareholders and must generate consistent profits in order to maintain a healthy stock valuation and pay dividends. Since equity financing is a greater risk to the investor than debt financing is to the lender, the cost of equity is often higher than the cost of debt.

How to Choose Between Debt and Equity

The amount of money that is required to obtain capital from different sources, called cost of capital, is crucial in determining a company's optimal capital structure. Cost of capital is expressed either as a percentage or as a dollar amount, depending on the context.

The cost of debt capital is represented by the interest rate required by the lender. A $100,000 loan with an interest rate of 6%has acost of capital of 6%,and a total cost of capital of $6,000. However, because payments on debt are tax-deductible, many cost of debt calculations take into account the corporate tax rate.

Assuming the tax rate is 30%, the above loan would have an after-tax cost of capital of 4.2%.

Cost of Equity Calculations

The cost of equity financing requires a rather straightforward calculation involving the capital asset pricing model or CAPM:

CAPM=RiskFreeRate(Company’sBeta×RiskPremium)\text{CAPM}=\frac{\text{Risk Free Rate}}{(\text{Company's Beta}\ \times\ \text{Risk Premium)}}CAPM=(Company’sBeta×RiskPremium)RiskFreeRate

By taking into account the returns generated by the larger market, as well as the individual stock's relative performance (represented by beta), the cost of equity calculation reflects the percentage of each invested dollar that shareholders expect in returns.

Finding the mix of debt and equity financing that yields the best funding at the lowest cost is a basic tenet of any prudent business strategy. To compare different capital structures, corporate accountants use a formula called the weighted average cost of capital, or WACC.

The WACC multiplies the percentage costs of debt—after accounting for the corporate tax rate—and equity under each proposed financing plan by a weight equal to the proportion of total capital represented by each capital type.

This allows businesses to determine which levels of debt and equity financing are most cost-effective.

Should a Company Issue Debt or Equity? (2024)

FAQs

Should a Company Issue Debt or Equity? ›

A company would choose debt financing

debt financing
Debt financing occurs when a company raises money by selling debt instruments to investors. Debt financing is the opposite of equity financing, which entails issuing stock to raise money. Debt financing occurs when a firm sells fixed income products, such as bonds, bills, or notes.
https://www.investopedia.com › terms › debtfinancing
over equity financing if it doesn't want to surrender any part of its company. A company that believes in its financials would not want to miss on the profits they would have to pass to shareholders if they assigned someone else equity.

Is debt or equity better for a company? ›

For larger, more mature companies, debt generally far outweighs equity in terms of benefits. Mid-growth companies still face a fair amount of risk, however. If you're still staking a foothold in your marketplace, equity may be the better option.

Why would a company issue equity instead of debt? ›

With equity financing, there is no loan to repay. The business doesn't have to make a monthly loan payment which can be particularly important if the business doesn't initially generate a profit. This in turn, gives you the freedom to channel more money into your growing business.

When should a company issue stock instead of debt? ›

If the venture for which the money needs to be raised does not have the ability to generate predictable cash flows in the immediate future, then the stock issue does make sense in such cases.

Does a company share its risk by issuing equity or debt? ›

The business is then beholden to shareholders and must generate consistent profits in order to maintain a healthy stock valuation and pay dividends. Since equity financing is a greater risk to the investor than debt financing is to the lender, the cost of equity is often higher than the cost of debt.

Why would a company issue debt? ›

By issuing debt (e.g., corporate bonds), companies are able to raise capital from investors. Using debt, the company becomes a borrower and the bondholders of the issue are the creditors (lenders). Unlike equity capital, debt does not involve diluting the ownership of the firm and does not carry voting rights.

What happens if a company has more debt than equity? ›

A high debt-to-equity ratio comes with high risk. If the ratio is high, it means that the company is lending capital from others to finance its growth. As a result, lenders and Investors often lean towards the company which has a lower debt-to-equity ratio.

What is the disadvantage of issuing debt over equity? ›

Because equity financing is a greater risk to the investor than debt financing is to the lender, debt financing is often less costly than equity financing. The main disadvantage of debt financing is that interest must be paid to lenders, which means that the amount paid will exceed the amount borrowed.

Why would a company issue equity? ›

Equity financing is the process of raising capital through the sale of shares. Companies raise money because they might have a short-term need to pay bills or need funds for a long-term project that promotes growth. By selling shares, a business effectively sells ownership of its company in return for cash.

What is a disadvantage of equity financing? ›

Equity Financing also has some disadvantages as compared to other methods of raising capital, including: The company gives up a portion of ownership. Leaders may be forced to consult with investors when making a decision. Equity typically costs more than debt financing due to higher risk.

Which is high risk equity or debt? ›

Debt funds offer stable returns with lower risk, while equity funds have the potential for higher returns but higher risk. Debt funds generate income through interest, while equity funds generate income through dividends and capital gains.

Which is more expensive, cost of equity or debt? ›

Equity capital reflects ownership while debt capital reflects an obligation. Typically, the cost of equity exceeds the cost of debt. The risk to shareholders is greater than to lenders since payment on a debt is required by law regardless of a company's profit margins.

Why is more debt better than equity? ›

Indeed, debt has a real cost to it, the interest payable. But equity has a hidden cost, the financial return shareholders expect to make. This hidden cost of equity is higher than that of debt since equity is a riskier investment. Interest cost can be deducted from income, lowering its post-tax cost further.

Why is debt investment better than equity? ›

Investments in debt securities typically involve less risk than equity investments and offer a lower potential return on investment. Debt investments fluctuate less in price than stocks. Even if a company is liquidated, bondholders are the first to be paid. Bonds are the most common form of debt investment.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Frankie Dare

Last Updated:

Views: 5371

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (73 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Frankie Dare

Birthday: 2000-01-27

Address: Suite 313 45115 Caridad Freeway, Port Barabaraville, MS 66713

Phone: +3769542039359

Job: Sales Manager

Hobby: Baton twirling, Stand-up comedy, Leather crafting, Rugby, tabletop games, Jigsaw puzzles, Air sports

Introduction: My name is Frankie Dare, I am a funny, beautiful, proud, fair, pleasant, cheerful, enthusiastic person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.