Most Expensive Car Insurance (2024) (2024)

FAQs

Why is auto insurance so expensive in 2024? ›

Your particular driver profile, which includes factors like where you live, your age and your driving record, influences what you pay for car insurance. But rising car repair costs and an increase in disaster-related claims are significant reasons why car insurance rates are surging for many drivers.

Our analysis showed that, on average, Dodge and Tesla have the most expensive car insurance among 17 popular brands. Full coverage on Dodge vehicles costs an average of $354 per month or $4,242 per year, while full coverage on a Tesla vehicle averages to $251 per month or $3,007 per year.

With insurance groups ranging from 1 to 50, vehicles in group 50 are the most expensive to insure. The cars that fall into this group usually have high market values and expensive parts and repairs.

“Inefficient regulatory environments in states like California, New Jersey and New York, combined with inflation and increased catastrophic losses, have left consumers with fewer choices of insurers and higher costs,” he said.

Allstate is so expensive because car insurance is expensive in general, due to rising costs for insurers. Allstate's premiums may also reflect how competitively Allstate agents are paid, but at $781 per year, the average Allstate car insurance policy is actually cheaper than coverage from most competitors.

Young drivers ages 16 to 24 tend to have the most expensive car insurance. Drivers in this age group are often inexperienced and are more likely to get into car accidents and file insurance claims. As a result, car insurance companies often charge higher premiums to young drivers.

Is $100 a month for car insurance good? Our cost estimates show that 35-year-old married drivers with good credit and clean driving records pay an average of $144 per month for car insurance. Paying around $100 per month for quality auto coverage is a good deal.

The Honda CR-V is the cheapest car to insure out of the top-selling vehicles, with an average monthly auto insurance cost of $238. This is 16% less than the average cost across all vehicles analyzed. The CR-V's insurance cost is $163 less per month than the cost for the most expensive car to insure — the Tesla Model 3.

Geico generally has affordable rates for most drivers. However, the company does tend to be more expensive for drivers who have a recent accident, DUI or speeding ticket on their record.

Which car insurance group is the cheapest? ›

So it's important to understand insurance groups – after all, there are 50 of them in total. Cars in group 1 are the least risky from an underwriter's perspective and the cheapest to insure. Those in group 50 are the riskiest and most expensive – usually higher performance models and luxury SUVs.

Allstate

Allstate is one of the pricier major insurers in America, averaging as the most expensive out of the ten largest insurance providers.

The firm's Home Insurance Projection Report foresees a 6% rise in annual premiums in 2024. The increase will put the national average at $2,522 at the end of the year. With climate experts expecting a devastating hurricane season, home insurance costs are forecasted to surge even higher in 2025.

Car insurance costs have been on the rise, leaving drivers searching for ways to save on car ownership costs. In fact, according to a report from Bankrate, the average annual premium of full coverage auto insurance rose to $2,543 in 2024 — up 26% from the previous year.

The collective risk factor

You are particularly affected by where you live and the people directly around you. If you live in an area where there is a lot of car theft or a higher number of accidents, your insurance company may assume there is a higher risk that you will also have similar claims.

But after two years of increases, there are strong indications that auto loan rates could start to come back down in 2024 — perhaps by a substantial amount.

Factors such as longer repair times and more expensive rental car costs are resulting in rising prices, according to a report by the American Property Casualty Insurance Association. Also, cars are becoming costlier to fix.

Car insurance typically drops as you grow older, when you drive safely for three to five years following an accident or citation, and when you switch to a cheaper company. Both men and women see the steepest drop in car insurance costs between ages 18 and 19.